Metal roofing has a reputation some earned, much of it not. If you’re comparing materials for your Wichita home, separating myth from reality can save you thousands over the life of the roof. Here’s a straightforward guide from American Roofing & Construction explaining the common metal roofing myths and misconceptions and the facts hidden behind them.
Myth #1: “Metal roofs are loud in the rain.”
In a modern home, metal panels sit over solid decking, underlayment, and insulation. That layered system dampens most of the sound. Oftentimes the sound of rain on a metal roof is similar to, or quieter than, that of asphalt shingles.
- Our advice: Ask your contractor to specify the deck type, underlayment, and any sound-dampening options. A continuous plywood deck with quality underlayment is key for reducing sound.
Myth #2: “Metal roofs attract lightning.”
Lightning strikes the highest and most conductive path to ground. A metal roof doesn’t “attract” lightning, but if a strike occurs, metal can safely dissipate energy and is non-combustible, reducing fire risk.
- Our advice: For tall or exposed homes on open land, discuss surge protection and proper grounding with a qualified electrician.
Myth #3: “Hail destroys metal roofs.”
Hail can dent softer metals and low-profile panels, but impact-rated systems and higher-profile designs resist damage well. Cosmetic dents (if they happen) don’t always affect performance. In many cases, metal roofing is naturally a class 4 impact rated roofing material. This makes it inherently more impact-resistant than asphalt shingles.
- Wichita specific advice: Ask about impact resistance ratings and panel profiles that hide minor dents. Keep a photo log of your roof after big hail events for insurance documentation.
Myth #4: “Metal roofs make your home hotter.”
Reflective coatings/finishes on today’s metal roofing can reduce heat gain versus darker, older shingles. In addition, attic ventilation and insulation matter more than color alone.
- Pro tip: Have your contractor verify balanced soffit intake + ridge exhaust. If you’re re-roofing, consider topping off attic insulation while access is easy.
Myth #5: “Metal roofs rust quickly.”
Modern residential steel panels use protective metallic coatings (e.g., galvanized or aluminum-zinc) plus durable paint finishes. With correct installation and maintenance, rust is not typical on residential systems.
- Our recommendation: Confirm the panel substrate (galvanized vs. aluminum-zinc), paint system, and coastal/corrosion warranty terms (even in Kansas, it’s smart to know).
Myth #6: “Metal roofing is too heavy for my house.”
Most residential metal roofs are lightweight, often comparable to or lighter than asphalt per square foot, and far lighter than tile or slate.
- If you have structural questions, ask for a quick framing check during the estimate. Metal can be a great option for older homes because of the lower weight.
Myth #7: “You can’t install metal on an existing home.”
Standing seam and metal shingle profiles fit a wide range of styles, from historic to contemporary. Color, seam height, and trim details can complement neighborhood aesthetics. There are also metal shingles available for homeowners looking for a more traditional roof look.
- Quick tip: Request mockups or photos of similar Wichita homes. Drive-by references help you picture the finished look.
Myth #8: “Metal roofs are maintenance-free.”
While metal roofing is low-maintenance, it’s not no-maintenance. You’ll still want periodic inspections, debris removal, and attention to sealants and flashing over time, just like any roof.
- Good rule of thumb: Plan a quick annual inspection (and after major storms). Keep valleys, gutters, and around penetrations clear to prevent water backups.
Myth #9: “Metal roofs are hard to repair if something goes wrong.”
Trained crews can replace panels, flashings, or accessories. The key is choosing compatible parts and a contractor who routinely installs metal roofing systems.
- Keep in mind: Choose a roofer with documented metal experience and Wichita references. Keep your warranty and finish color code on file for matching.
Myth #10: “Insurance always gives a discount for metal roofing.”
Some carriers do—especially for impact-rated systems—others don’t. Policies vary by company and by roof profile. Before you sign, call your agent with the exact product and rating to confirm potential discounts and how cosmetic hail damage is treated.
- Additional advice: Check out any other potential energy savings related to energy efficiency. Many types of metal roofs are more energy efficient than asphalt shingles. This may qualify homeowners for specific tax credits and energy efficient benefits.
What Matters Most: Installation & Details
Regardless of brand, the performance of a metal roof relies on the details:
- Substrate & Finish: Steel type, coating, and paint system.
- Underlayment: High-temp synthetic or peel-and-stick where needed (valleys, eaves).
- Flashing: Chimneys, walls, skylights, and transitions must be custom-bent and correctly lapped.
- Ventilation: Balanced intake/exhaust to protect the deck and regulate attic climate.
- Fastening & Clips: Match panel design, allow for thermal movement, and follow manufacturer spacing.
- Edge Metal & Seams: Drip edges, ridge caps, and hemmed eaves resist wind uplift—important in Kansas storms.
Ask for these items in writing on your estimate and closeout package (with photos). It’s your proof that the right steps were taken.
Wichita Homeowner Checklist
- Get a roof inspection focused on hail history, decking condition, ventilation, and flashing.
- Confirm specifications: panel type (standing seam or metal shingle), substrate, finish, underlayment, flashing plan, ventilation plan.
- Review warranties: materials, finish/paint, and workmanship—know what voids coverage.
- Verify experience: local Wichita references for metal jobs, not just shingles.
- Discuss storm realities: hail strategy (impact rating/profile), wind uplift details, and how cosmetic damage is handled.
- Align with your insurer: provide the exact product/rating to your agent before you sign.
- Plan maintenance: quick annual check and post-storm review; keep a photo log.
Ready to Explore Metal for Your Wichita Home?
American Roofing & Construction helps homeowners in Wichita, Andover, Maize, Goddard, and Derby compare options without the sales pressure. We’ll inspect your current roof, explain metal vs. asphalt in simple terms, and give you a clear, line-item estimate—repair when it’s enough, replace only when it’s right.
Book your free roof inspection today. We’ll bring photos, specs, and straightforward answers so you can make a confident decision.